volunteer engagement strategies

This is Part 1 of a two-part series.  You’ll find Part 2 HERE >> 

12 Innovative Volunteer Engagement Strategies for the New “Normal” – Part 1 

The Top Line:

The world has changed — and so has volunteerism. From shifting workforce dynamics to new expectations around flexibility and purpose, today’s volunteers show up differently than they did just a few years ago. In this post (Part 1 of a two‑part series), we’ll explore the current context reshaping volunteer engagement and set the stage for practical strategies to rebuild, innovate, and thrive.

Read on to Discover:

Following major disruptions to community involvement, many nonprofits still struggle to adjust their volunteer engagement strategies to meet new realities.

If you’re in this boat, you may be asking yourself – How can I re-engage former volunteers who haven’t yet returned? How do I convince the public that volunteering is worth it when safety concerns still exist? How do I attract volunteers from new and diverse communities we haven’t reached before?  

You might also wonder – How can I lead through uncertainty when I can’t predict the future? 

All completely understandable questions. A lot has changed. 

In Chapter 1 of Volunteer Engagement 2.0, I argued that as society evolves, so too does volunteerism.  

So, what happens when a slow evolution is accelerated by a global existential crisis? 

A lot, it turns out. 

For more of my thoughts on the vital role volunteerism plays in today’s world, check out Why is Volunteerism Important Right Now? HERE >>

volunteer engagement strategies

The Current Context: What’s Impacting Your Volunteer Engagement Strategies  

Consider what’s currently impacting the people who volunteer, their choices, their very way of life.  

What stressors are they managing? How do current events impact people’s willingness to volunteer and their ongoing loyalty to an organization?  

How should this impact how you plan your volunteer engagement strategies? 

If you’re wondering what the data says, it’s sobering.  

  • According to the World Health Organization (WHO), more than one billion people globally live with mental health conditions such as anxiety and depression — a crisis that continues to affect communities worldwide.
  • We live in a world where post-viral conditions like long COVID remain a real concern. Studies have found that a significant percentage of those who contract COVID-19 experience lingering symptoms, even after mild initial illness. At the same time, individuals continue to have differing views on health and safety protocols, making a one-size-fits-all approach to volunteer engagement impractical.
  • Workforce dynamics have shifted profoundly. Help wanted signs remain common across many industries as employees continue to prioritize work-life balance, flexibility, and meaningful engagement over traditional job perks. People have become more discerning about how they spend each valuable moment — a mindset that directly affects volunteerism.
  • Societies are now fraught by intense political divisions – punctuated by a sharp rise in deadly violence – that only are becoming even more entrenched. Our political leaders appear to have lost the ability to find the common ground so essential to progress in the arena of governance. As a result, neighbors, colleagues, fellow volunteers, and even family members are now less trusted by one another. We’re not sure if we share cherished values anymore, and we’re not sure if we want to find out. Further, as we emerge from pandemic lockdowns, we engage in face-to-face interactions with uncertainty and a lack of ease around social cues and traditions. It’s a bumpy ride back. 
  • Behind it all is the constant hum of news about our current climate crisis – new predictions about the rate of change and shocking new weather patterns that boost our levels of anxiety about what appears impossible to control. Meanwhile, extreme weather events wreak real havoc on communities and natural disasters claim lives.In addition, inflationary prices on a global scale – most notably for fuel, food, and travel – are affecting families as they work to stretch their paychecks and worry about a coming recession.
  • Finally,  the technology landscape continues to evolve. While many nonprofits and volunteers have embraced digital tools, concerns about screen time, algorithmic bias, and the rapid rise of artificial intelligence have made audiences more discerning about how and where they engage online.
     
    We now know that Zoom Fatigue is real. We know that algorithms tend to limit, not expand, our exploration of the world, and that exposure to devices in infancy and on into childhood can impede cognitive development. We understand that bad actors can, and do, use tech platforms for nefarious ends. Also, as creators and communicators, we now know it’s getting harder and harder to build an audience online (or on land for that matter), which also makes it hard to sustain successful volunteer engagement strategies. 

If you haven’t realized it yet – humanity is in a heap of trouble … and not good trouble. 

Does this mean that volunteer engagement strategies are doomed to fail? What can nonprofits and other volunteer-driven organizations do? 

As society evolves, so too does volunteerism. 

I would argue that volunteerism and community engagement may be the very solution to many of the challenges facing humankind today. 

As cultural anthropologist Margaret Mead is often quoted, “Never doubt that a small group of thoughtful, committed citizens can change the world; indeed, it’s the only thing that ever has.” 

People create problems. People can also create solutions. 

And, when we do so collectively and en force, powerful change can happen. 

volunteer engagement strategies

Volunteer Engagement Strategies: Innovation for Today’s World 

If you’ve been apt to think of volunteers as simply “free labor” for your nonprofit, that ship has sailed. 

If the Great Resignation has taught us anything, it’s that people simply do not want to be taken for granted. Full stop. 

When volunteers are treated as replaceable “widgets” to fill “slots,” your volunteer engagement strategies aren’t going to get far. 

So, the time, money, and effort needed to evolve our volunteer engagement strategies…worth it? 

In the face of tremendous economic and psychic pressures for people from all parts of society, we might question whether it is worth it at all to try to implement new volunteer engagement strategies. 

Rest assured, engaging volunteers (if done safely) is still an ethical practice. 

Meaningful service is also good for our organization, good for our communities, and good for volunteers themselves. 

Numerous studies have shown that volunteering is good for the health of humans.  

Some research has shown that services provided by volunteers are considered more relational and are perceived as more equal, flexible and sincere than services provided by paid staff.  

Equally important, robust volunteer involvement can affect a nonprofit’s sustainability in specific ways. As the National Center for Family Philanthropy notes:  

  • Organizations that leverage volunteers and their skills extensively to meet their missions are significantly more adaptable, sustainable, and capable of going to scale.
  • Organizations that engage volunteers are equally as effective in carrying out their mission as those without volunteers, and at almost half the median budget.
  • Volunteers contribute up to ten times more than non-volunteers, and most make financial donations to the organizations in which they are involved.
  • Effective volunteer engagement has been shown to reap up to a $6 return for every dollar invested in volunteer involvement.  

So, yes. Finding a way through today’s challenges to rebuild our community engagement and renovate our volunteer engagement strategies is not only nice, doing so may be necessary to our survival. 

Volunteers can change the world.  

Indeed. 

For some quick tips to get started, check out How to Thrive in Changing Times: Two Key Shifts to Make in Your Nonprofit Management HERE >> 

Stay Tuned for Part 2 

Now that I’ve set the stage, in the second part of this post, “12 Innovative Volunteer Engagement Strategies for the New “Normal” – Part 2,” I’ll continue the discussion about what specific steps can be taken, and innovations made, to actively engage volunteers in today’s world. 

Consider it an “operations plan” of sorts, or a blueprint for the year ahead. 

It doesn’t matter whether you’re reading this at the beginning of the year, end of the year, or somewhere in the middle, upgrading your volunteer engagement strategies is an “evergreen” activity.  

As society evolves, so too does volunteerism. 

We must continue to grow our practice of volunteer engagement as the arc of history continues, and science offers up more about our human experience and what might reduce barriers and bring us more closely together. 

We are amid massive global disruption.  

Disruptions create openings and opportunities for new ways of being and doing for the greater good. 

In next week’s post, I’ll share some of the ways you can create an opening for the future and how you can lead through uncertainty (even when you can’t predict where the future will lead).